THEMATIC REPERTORY AND MATERIA MEDICA OF THE MIND SYMPTOMS – Jose Antonio Mirilli
INTRODUCTION
Thematic (adj.) of the basic word Theme, which means a subject being discussed or a melody which is repeated in a work.
This book is named so, as it contains words, or words and its synonyms, or words with its antonyms which are repeatedly told by the patient with a special delight or emphasis.
Hahnemann used to consider the mental symptoms as the most valuable when choosing a medicine.
§ 210 - whenever there is a disease that we must heal, the general health must get the same special attention as the totality of the symptoms.
§ 211 – This is so true that the choice of the homeopathic medicine is often determined by the state of mind of the patient which is a very characteristic symptom.
§ 212 – The creator of therapeutical agents also observed this main characteristic of all disease, the physical and spiritual altered states.
§ 213 – Thus if we do not see among the other symptoms in each disease, even the grave ones, the symptoms related to changes in mental and moral conditions we will never be able to heal according to nature, that is, homeopathically.
AUTHOR
Dr. Jose Antonio Mirilli, MD is a Brazilian Homoeopath.
CONTRIBUTIONS
• Repertório Temático (English-Portuguese), 1993-1996.
• Matéria Médica Temática (English), 1994-1996.
• Dicionário Temático (English), 1994.
• Matéria Médica Temática (Portuguese) - Robe Publisher, 1996.
EMERGENCE OF THEMATIC REPERTORY
The symptoms of a Pure Materia Medica seemed to the author totally unintelligent. Later he understood the experimental nature of homoeopathical symptoms and started thinking about how hard it was to study the symptoms that are spread along the several volumes of Materia Medica. He wondered if there was an easier way of organizing the symptoms for the homeopathists. When he discovered Bernal’s thematic work he foresaw the possibility of organizing the homeopathic symptoms of the Pure Materia Medica by themes.
This work is an aid to understand the mental pictures of many of the polychrests using keywords and themes.
SOURCES
The following Materia Medica's were used for quotations:
• Materia Medica Pura and Chronic Diseases of Hahnemann.
• T.F. Allen’s Encyclopedia, and The supplementary symptoms of the tenth volume.
• H.C. Allen’s Materia Medica of the Nosodes.
• Hering Guiding symptoms.
• Jeremy Sherr’s Dynamic Provings, vol.1.
BOOK PROPER
REPERTORY PROPER
1st published in the year 1994 & revised edition came in 1998.
TABLE OF CONTENTS:
• Foreword by VII-XIV
• Introduction by the Author XV
• Thematic Repertory Index- Alphabetical List of Themes XIX
• Analogical Index of Themes and Synonyms XXIII
• Index of Remedies of the Alphabetical list of Pure Materia XXXVII
• Thematic Repertory- Symptoms of Repertory and Pure Materia Medica ordered by Themes 1-814
• The Study of Words 815-818
• Pure Materia Medica Word Index 819-874
• Alphabetic List of Pure Materia Medica Symptoms 875-1086
• Remedies and Abbreviations 1087-1110
• Abbreviations and Remedies 1111-1134
• The Author's identification and frequency list 1135-1137
FOREWORD AND INTRODUCTION
FOREWORD is given by seven authors of this century who have appreciated his work as it makes the study of mind symptoms of Pure Materia medica easy.
INTRODUCTION (includes the STUDY OF WORDS, in revised edition) the author has mentioned as how he got the idea of writing this book. Initially he attempted on reading the homoeopathic symptoms and did an analogical research of the key words of the symptoms in English and later used those words to create the themes. He has spent 5 years in researching and organizing the Pure Materia Medica symptoms.
INTRODUCTION BY AUTHOR
The main aim of the repertory is to classify the homoeopathic symptoms so they could be used by the homoeopaths for fast medical advice, but there are four limitations, as mentioned below:
• The symptoms being served and classified in alphabetical order have no connections and loose their dynamic expressions.
• The symptoms come from several sources, but the similar symptoms are at different places and are not related.
• The symptoms taken from Pure Materia Medica are not totally represented in rubric form.
• There is a great difference in vocabulary between the Repertory and Materia medica. In Repertory the symptoms are organized not by description but according to the author’s own perception and awareness of reality.
It is not enough to add new medicines in the rubrics but we have to review its concepts and create new rubrics. For example – classical symptoms such as “anxiety of conscience” are explained now-a-days as the “guilt” according to psychoanalytic concept.
For replacing old terminologies with the present, various dictionaries have been used, e.g. “The American Heritage”, “Webster’s old unabridged edition”, “Aurelio Portuguese dictionary”, “Houaiss” English Portuguese dictionary and the CD-ROM “Microsoft Bookshelf”.
In compiling the work, the author has attempted to satisfy these points by putting all the related rubrics of the symptoms under one theme and giving the medicines with original source in the proving.
In Barthel's Repertory, e.g., symptoms of Pulsatilla are related to the forsaken theme: - Delusions; alone, she is always, - Delusions; alone world, she is a. in the, - Delusions; deserted, forsaken, is - Delusions; neglected, of being, - Fear; neglected of being, - Forsaken; isolation, sensation of.
In Hahnemann's Materia Medica, the complete symptom is given (Ha,1143): "Her head is so quiet and all about her is so empty as if she were alone in the house and in the world; she doesn’t wish to talk to any one, just as if all around her were no concern of her and she belonged to nobody."
In Pure Materia Medica, we can observe that certain words give significance to symptoms, and these are the theme words. We can make a group of theme words and create thematic groups. It was necessary to deeply scrutinize the meaning of most important words present in symptoms in the English language, and to search for their analogues, and look for resemblances. A dictionary with more than 4,000 words in English language was created, with main words of PMM mental symptoms, and their synonyms. The meanings of the Words are exemplified by the symptoms in which they occur rather than from the dictionary.
For example - the word hypochondria, in the classical texts, can be, in some symptoms, similar to melancholia or other symptoms - fear of illness, or illusion of illness - like in the contemporary dictionary meaning. These studies resulted in the compilation of the Thematic Dictionary.
The author used the Thematic Dictionary as a side repertory, extending the entry menu of traditional Repertories.
The nomenclature of the bibliographical references given at the end of each medicine, refer as:
• Ha- with numbering below 200 is for the Chronic Diseases and above 200 for Hahnemann’s Materia Medica Pura.
• Al- for the T.F. Allen’s Encyclopedia, Al-S for the supplementary symptoms of the tenth volume.
• Al-N- for the symptoms of the H.C. Allen’s Materia Medica of the Nosodes.
• He- for the symptoms taken from Hering’s Guiding Symptoms.
• Sh- for the symptoms taken from Jeremy Sherr’s Dynamic Provings, vol.1
INDEX OF THEMES AND PAGE NUMBER
Abroad 1 Accidents 1 Accused 5 Alive 5 Ambition 6 Anger 8 Animal 27 Antagonism 41 Anticipation 48 Approached 52 Attacked 54 Avarice 58 Betrayed 59 Bite 62 Blood 64 Bother 66 Bothered 67 Bright 72 Brother 76 Burn 76 Busy 77 Camouflage 79 Capricious 80 Cares 82 Caught 84 Censorious 84 Censured 89 Child 92 Clairvoyance 98 Clothes 99 Company 102 Compassionate 108 Conducted 112 Confidence 112 Conscience 119 Conscientious 138 Consolation 141 Constriction 141 Contemptuous 142 Contradiction 148 Contrary 151 Corpse 152 Cowardice 153 Crawling 156 Criminal 158 Crowd 162 Crushed 163 Damage 164 Danger 166 Dark 170 Death 175 Deceitful 197 Defiant 198 Despair 199 Despised 206 Devil 210 Dictatorial 213 Dirty 214 Disappointment 218 Discontented 220 Discussion 222 Disease 224 ……. Young 975
INDEX OF THEMES
More than 4,000 symptoms from 17,000 that compound the Pure Materia Medicas mental symptoms were selected and 300 mental themes were formed.
Someone may ask what about the rest of the 13,000 symptoms?
A theme listing is a collection of repertory rubrics (from Complete Repertory) related to one theme. For example, in the Thematic Repertory, the theme 'Water' contains all the rubrics with the word water but also incorporates rubrics with drowning, drinking, fishes, ships, rain, wet and washing.
AN ANALOGICAL INDEX
• In this references are given to themes (e.g. 'Abandoned', see theme 'Forsaken').
• At the end of the repertory an index where all Complete repertory mind rubrics referring to the themes in the repertory in which these rubrics are incorporated has been given.
THEMATIC REPERTORY
Symptoms of repertory and pure materia medica ordered by themes are arranged in this part.
Example from the book:
FORSAKEN (Based on The Complete Repertory)
Anxiety; forsaken her, as if a friend had: rhus-t.54
Blackmail, emotional, says "you don't love me" when refused: puls.189 tub.189
Company, desire for; children that are re-jected, in: carc.207
Confidence; thinks others have none, which makes her unhappy, and: aur.
Delusions; alone, always: puls. stram.
alone, castaway, being a: germ.222 phys.54
alone, world, she is a. in the: androc. bamb-a.1184 camph. choc.222 cycl.122 germ.222 hura plat. puls.
appreciated, she is not: arg-n.185 aur.185 lap-c-b.194 pall. plat. puls.162 seq-s.230
asylum, insane, sent to: lach.58
Materia Medica
ANDROC. Sh, 61- Felt constrained and had a gloomy approach to everything, averse company, desire to be alone. I feel people will not want to talk or be with me. (28) Sh, 63- Desired company but could not be bothered to see anyone, felt lonely as if he didn't belong. (21)
ARG-N. He, 40 - Melancholy since an undeserved slight (scorn); fixed idea that he was neglected and despised by his family; his callings (job, work) became indifferent to him.
AUR-M. He, 6- Everything is disagreeable, dreary (lugubrious, desolate, deserted), even nature around.
AUR. Ha, 3- He believes that he has lost the love of others, and this mortifies him even to tears. Ha, 353- He imagines he has forfeited (penalty, lost,) the affections of others, and this grieves him to tears.
BAR-C. Ha, 6- Sad and anxious; all manner of gloomy (sad) ideas as to his future fate (destiny) rise in his mind, and believes himself totally forsaken (deserted); in the evening.
COMPUTER REPERTORIES
• The use of a thematic approach has been incorporated into Cara Professional with the co-operation with Dr. José Mirilli who has pioneered the use of this approach as a more accurate and meaningful way of finding the indicated remedy.
• The Millenium Edition of the Complete repertory has included a chapter on Themes. This allows to quickly see which remedies are associated with a theme and the verifying rubrics, which is based on the work of Dr Jose Mirilli.
CONCLUSION
The author has himself told that he uses this repertory as a side reference along with the traditional repertories in his clinic.
There are some other views from other practitioners regarding this valuable work.
The thematic classification gave us the possibility to observe the psychodynamics of each medicine. It is a very useful work to establish the fine distinctions between rubrics as well as work from which one can study Pure Materia Medica. This book enables us, once we recognize the theme running through the case, to approach it using the provers' own expressions, and differentiate between numerous remedies.
This book offers reference possibilities which go far beyond a standard word search or any repertory format we are acquainted with.
It's clinically applicable, it enables the homoeopath to explore a theme running through the proving of a remedy. In grouping by themes, the comparative function of the repertory is enhanced without loosing any differentiation.
Its open concept leaves a lot of space for improvements, alterations and additions by the homoeopathic community.
REFERENCES
– The Principles and Practice of Repertorization – Dr. K. Harinadham
– www.minimum.com
– www.geocities.com
– www.wholehealthnow.com
– www.homoeopathic.com
Thematic (adj.) of the basic word Theme, which means a subject being discussed or a melody which is repeated in a work.
This book is named so, as it contains words, or words and its synonyms, or words with its antonyms which are repeatedly told by the patient with a special delight or emphasis.
Hahnemann used to consider the mental symptoms as the most valuable when choosing a medicine.
§ 210 - whenever there is a disease that we must heal, the general health must get the same special attention as the totality of the symptoms.
§ 211 – This is so true that the choice of the homeopathic medicine is often determined by the state of mind of the patient which is a very characteristic symptom.
§ 212 – The creator of therapeutical agents also observed this main characteristic of all disease, the physical and spiritual altered states.
§ 213 – Thus if we do not see among the other symptoms in each disease, even the grave ones, the symptoms related to changes in mental and moral conditions we will never be able to heal according to nature, that is, homeopathically.
AUTHOR
Dr. Jose Antonio Mirilli, MD is a Brazilian Homoeopath.
CONTRIBUTIONS
• Repertório Temático (English-Portuguese), 1993-1996.
• Matéria Médica Temática (English), 1994-1996.
• Dicionário Temático (English), 1994.
• Matéria Médica Temática (Portuguese) - Robe Publisher, 1996.
EMERGENCE OF THEMATIC REPERTORY
The symptoms of a Pure Materia Medica seemed to the author totally unintelligent. Later he understood the experimental nature of homoeopathical symptoms and started thinking about how hard it was to study the symptoms that are spread along the several volumes of Materia Medica. He wondered if there was an easier way of organizing the symptoms for the homeopathists. When he discovered Bernal’s thematic work he foresaw the possibility of organizing the homeopathic symptoms of the Pure Materia Medica by themes.
This work is an aid to understand the mental pictures of many of the polychrests using keywords and themes.
SOURCES
The following Materia Medica's were used for quotations:
• Materia Medica Pura and Chronic Diseases of Hahnemann.
• T.F. Allen’s Encyclopedia, and The supplementary symptoms of the tenth volume.
• H.C. Allen’s Materia Medica of the Nosodes.
• Hering Guiding symptoms.
• Jeremy Sherr’s Dynamic Provings, vol.1.
BOOK PROPER
REPERTORY PROPER
1st published in the year 1994 & revised edition came in 1998.
TABLE OF CONTENTS:
• Foreword by VII-XIV
• Introduction by the Author XV
• Thematic Repertory Index- Alphabetical List of Themes XIX
• Analogical Index of Themes and Synonyms XXIII
• Index of Remedies of the Alphabetical list of Pure Materia XXXVII
• Thematic Repertory- Symptoms of Repertory and Pure Materia Medica ordered by Themes 1-814
• The Study of Words 815-818
• Pure Materia Medica Word Index 819-874
• Alphabetic List of Pure Materia Medica Symptoms 875-1086
• Remedies and Abbreviations 1087-1110
• Abbreviations and Remedies 1111-1134
• The Author's identification and frequency list 1135-1137
FOREWORD AND INTRODUCTION
FOREWORD is given by seven authors of this century who have appreciated his work as it makes the study of mind symptoms of Pure Materia medica easy.
INTRODUCTION (includes the STUDY OF WORDS, in revised edition) the author has mentioned as how he got the idea of writing this book. Initially he attempted on reading the homoeopathic symptoms and did an analogical research of the key words of the symptoms in English and later used those words to create the themes. He has spent 5 years in researching and organizing the Pure Materia Medica symptoms.
INTRODUCTION BY AUTHOR
The main aim of the repertory is to classify the homoeopathic symptoms so they could be used by the homoeopaths for fast medical advice, but there are four limitations, as mentioned below:
• The symptoms being served and classified in alphabetical order have no connections and loose their dynamic expressions.
• The symptoms come from several sources, but the similar symptoms are at different places and are not related.
• The symptoms taken from Pure Materia Medica are not totally represented in rubric form.
• There is a great difference in vocabulary between the Repertory and Materia medica. In Repertory the symptoms are organized not by description but according to the author’s own perception and awareness of reality.
It is not enough to add new medicines in the rubrics but we have to review its concepts and create new rubrics. For example – classical symptoms such as “anxiety of conscience” are explained now-a-days as the “guilt” according to psychoanalytic concept.
For replacing old terminologies with the present, various dictionaries have been used, e.g. “The American Heritage”, “Webster’s old unabridged edition”, “Aurelio Portuguese dictionary”, “Houaiss” English Portuguese dictionary and the CD-ROM “Microsoft Bookshelf”.
In compiling the work, the author has attempted to satisfy these points by putting all the related rubrics of the symptoms under one theme and giving the medicines with original source in the proving.
In Barthel's Repertory, e.g., symptoms of Pulsatilla are related to the forsaken theme: - Delusions; alone, she is always, - Delusions; alone world, she is a. in the, - Delusions; deserted, forsaken, is - Delusions; neglected, of being, - Fear; neglected of being, - Forsaken; isolation, sensation of.
In Hahnemann's Materia Medica, the complete symptom is given (Ha,1143): "Her head is so quiet and all about her is so empty as if she were alone in the house and in the world; she doesn’t wish to talk to any one, just as if all around her were no concern of her and she belonged to nobody."
In Pure Materia Medica, we can observe that certain words give significance to symptoms, and these are the theme words. We can make a group of theme words and create thematic groups. It was necessary to deeply scrutinize the meaning of most important words present in symptoms in the English language, and to search for their analogues, and look for resemblances. A dictionary with more than 4,000 words in English language was created, with main words of PMM mental symptoms, and their synonyms. The meanings of the Words are exemplified by the symptoms in which they occur rather than from the dictionary.
For example - the word hypochondria, in the classical texts, can be, in some symptoms, similar to melancholia or other symptoms - fear of illness, or illusion of illness - like in the contemporary dictionary meaning. These studies resulted in the compilation of the Thematic Dictionary.
The author used the Thematic Dictionary as a side repertory, extending the entry menu of traditional Repertories.
The nomenclature of the bibliographical references given at the end of each medicine, refer as:
• Ha- with numbering below 200 is for the Chronic Diseases and above 200 for Hahnemann’s Materia Medica Pura.
• Al- for the T.F. Allen’s Encyclopedia, Al-S for the supplementary symptoms of the tenth volume.
• Al-N- for the symptoms of the H.C. Allen’s Materia Medica of the Nosodes.
• He- for the symptoms taken from Hering’s Guiding Symptoms.
• Sh- for the symptoms taken from Jeremy Sherr’s Dynamic Provings, vol.1
INDEX OF THEMES AND PAGE NUMBER
Abroad 1 Accidents 1 Accused 5 Alive 5 Ambition 6 Anger 8 Animal 27 Antagonism 41 Anticipation 48 Approached 52 Attacked 54 Avarice 58 Betrayed 59 Bite 62 Blood 64 Bother 66 Bothered 67 Bright 72 Brother 76 Burn 76 Busy 77 Camouflage 79 Capricious 80 Cares 82 Caught 84 Censorious 84 Censured 89 Child 92 Clairvoyance 98 Clothes 99 Company 102 Compassionate 108 Conducted 112 Confidence 112 Conscience 119 Conscientious 138 Consolation 141 Constriction 141 Contemptuous 142 Contradiction 148 Contrary 151 Corpse 152 Cowardice 153 Crawling 156 Criminal 158 Crowd 162 Crushed 163 Damage 164 Danger 166 Dark 170 Death 175 Deceitful 197 Defiant 198 Despair 199 Despised 206 Devil 210 Dictatorial 213 Dirty 214 Disappointment 218 Discontented 220 Discussion 222 Disease 224 ……. Young 975
INDEX OF THEMES
More than 4,000 symptoms from 17,000 that compound the Pure Materia Medicas mental symptoms were selected and 300 mental themes were formed.
Someone may ask what about the rest of the 13,000 symptoms?
A theme listing is a collection of repertory rubrics (from Complete Repertory) related to one theme. For example, in the Thematic Repertory, the theme 'Water' contains all the rubrics with the word water but also incorporates rubrics with drowning, drinking, fishes, ships, rain, wet and washing.
AN ANALOGICAL INDEX
• In this references are given to themes (e.g. 'Abandoned', see theme 'Forsaken').
• At the end of the repertory an index where all Complete repertory mind rubrics referring to the themes in the repertory in which these rubrics are incorporated has been given.
THEMATIC REPERTORY
Symptoms of repertory and pure materia medica ordered by themes are arranged in this part.
Example from the book:
FORSAKEN (Based on The Complete Repertory)
Anxiety; forsaken her, as if a friend had: rhus-t.54
Blackmail, emotional, says "you don't love me" when refused: puls.189 tub.189
Company, desire for; children that are re-jected, in: carc.207
Confidence; thinks others have none, which makes her unhappy, and: aur.
Delusions; alone, always: puls. stram.
alone, castaway, being a: germ.222 phys.54
alone, world, she is a. in the: androc. bamb-a.1184 camph. choc.222 cycl.122 germ.222 hura plat. puls.
appreciated, she is not: arg-n.185 aur.185 lap-c-b.194 pall. plat. puls.162 seq-s.230
asylum, insane, sent to: lach.58
Materia Medica
ANDROC. Sh, 61- Felt constrained and had a gloomy approach to everything, averse company, desire to be alone. I feel people will not want to talk or be with me. (28) Sh, 63- Desired company but could not be bothered to see anyone, felt lonely as if he didn't belong. (21)
ARG-N. He, 40 - Melancholy since an undeserved slight (scorn); fixed idea that he was neglected and despised by his family; his callings (job, work) became indifferent to him.
AUR-M. He, 6- Everything is disagreeable, dreary (lugubrious, desolate, deserted), even nature around.
AUR. Ha, 3- He believes that he has lost the love of others, and this mortifies him even to tears. Ha, 353- He imagines he has forfeited (penalty, lost,) the affections of others, and this grieves him to tears.
BAR-C. Ha, 6- Sad and anxious; all manner of gloomy (sad) ideas as to his future fate (destiny) rise in his mind, and believes himself totally forsaken (deserted); in the evening.
COMPUTER REPERTORIES
• The use of a thematic approach has been incorporated into Cara Professional with the co-operation with Dr. José Mirilli who has pioneered the use of this approach as a more accurate and meaningful way of finding the indicated remedy.
• The Millenium Edition of the Complete repertory has included a chapter on Themes. This allows to quickly see which remedies are associated with a theme and the verifying rubrics, which is based on the work of Dr Jose Mirilli.
CONCLUSION
The author has himself told that he uses this repertory as a side reference along with the traditional repertories in his clinic.
There are some other views from other practitioners regarding this valuable work.
The thematic classification gave us the possibility to observe the psychodynamics of each medicine. It is a very useful work to establish the fine distinctions between rubrics as well as work from which one can study Pure Materia Medica. This book enables us, once we recognize the theme running through the case, to approach it using the provers' own expressions, and differentiate between numerous remedies.
This book offers reference possibilities which go far beyond a standard word search or any repertory format we are acquainted with.
It's clinically applicable, it enables the homoeopath to explore a theme running through the proving of a remedy. In grouping by themes, the comparative function of the repertory is enhanced without loosing any differentiation.
Its open concept leaves a lot of space for improvements, alterations and additions by the homoeopathic community.
REFERENCES
– The Principles and Practice of Repertorization – Dr. K. Harinadham
– www.minimum.com
– www.geocities.com
– www.wholehealthnow.com
– www.homoeopathic.com
Comments
Post a Comment
PLEASE WRITE YOUR SYMPTOMS HERE TO GET SUGGESTION.